Argumentative Essay Outline- Hamlet
Thesis Question: Was Ophelia’s death accidental or suicide?
Ophelia’s death was an accident.
Reason #1: Ophelia is insane. Crazy people would not be able to think of suicide, they are typically happy.
Example: “A person with psychosis experiences some loss of contact with reality, characterized by changes in their way of thinking, believing, perceiving and/or behaving.” (http://www.cmha.ca/BINS/content_page.asp?cid=3-105)
Explanation: This completely describes Ophelia. She definitely has a loss of contact with reality. You can see this during Act 4:
Ophelia: You sing A-down-a-down- And you, Call-him-a-
Down-a- Oh, how the wheel becomes it! It is the false
Steward that stole his master’s daughter.
(Hamlet, Act 4, scene v, l. 144-146)
She is making no sense whatsoever. This definitely signifies psychosis because she has changes in the way of her thinking as well as her behaviour. This loss of contact with reality means that she couldn’t have possibly committed suicide because her thought process was not all there.
Example: Laertes: Thought and affliction, passion, hell itself,
She turns to favour and prettiness.
(Hamlet, Act 4, scene v, l.158-159)
Explanation: Even Laertes believes she is insane. This quote shows that she seems to be happy in her insanity. She is not likely to commit suicide in this sort of mental state because she is happy.
Reason #2: Everyone regarded her death as an accident.
Example: Gertrude: […] There, on the pendant boughs her coronet weeds
Clambering to hang, an envious sliver broke,
When down her weedy trophies and herself
Fell in the weeping brook. Her clothes spread wide,
And mermaid-like a while they bore her up,
Which time she chanted snatches of old lauds
As one incapable of her own distress,
Or like a creature native and indued
Unto that element. But long it could not be
Till that of her garments, heavy with their drink,
Pulled the poor wretch from her melodious lay
To muddy death.
(Hamlet, Act 4, scene vii, l. 168- 179)
Explanation: Even Gertrude believed that Ophelia had simply fell into the water trying to hang her wreath in the tree. She drowned because her clothes spread out and made her sink and made her unable to swim (if she knew how to). If it had been a suicide attempt, she wouldn’t have fallen in climbing a tree, she would have just jumped into the water.
Example: Laertes: Lay her i’ th’earth,
And from her fari and unpolluted flesh
May violets spring! I tell thee, churlish priest,
A ministering angel shall my sister be
When thou liest howling.
(Hamlet, Act v, scene i., l. 213-217)
Explanation: Laertes never doubted that his sister’s death was an accident. When the priest made his comment on how she shouldn’t be buried here because her death was considered “suspicious,” Laertes defended his sister by saying that she definitely didn’t kill herself, and that she will be an angel and the priest will go to Hell for thinking such a thing about an innocent person.
Reason #3: Ophelia’s death is often related to her father’s murder. This is not true. Her reaction after her father’s death was simply a stage of grieving.
Example:
“Immediately after news of death, you will likely experience a period when you feel very little except a sense of unreality. Some people have described this period as being enclosed in a cocoon, or as “sleepwalking”, through the funeral and necessary details which follow death. This stage may last for several weeks or several months.”
(http://www.cmha.ca/BINS/content_page.asp?cid=2-63-65)
Explanation: As soon as someone close to you dies, you go through stages of grieving. The first one is numbness and shock. You can see this in Ophelia. After her father is killed, she experiences this sense of unreality:
Ophelia: He is dead and gone, lady,
He is dead and gone,
At his head a grass-green turf,
At his heels a stone.
(Hamlet, Act 4, scene v, l. 25-29)
This can explain they way she had been acting. It can also explains how her death is not a suicide. If it had been a suicide, it would be more likely that she would have done it soon after her father’s death. Since there was a certain amount of time between her death and her father’s, it is definitely not a suicide.
Anti- Reason (Ophelia’s death was a suicide): The death of he father caused her to commit suicide.
Example: Gentleman: She speaks much of her father, says she hears
Theres’s tricks i’th’world, and hems, and beats her heart,
Spurns enviously at straws, speaks things in doubt
That carry but half sense. Her speech is nothing,
Yet the unshaped us of it doth move
The hearers to collection. They aim at it,
And botch the words up fit to their own thoughts,
Which, as her winks and nods and gestures yield them,
Indeed would make one think there might be thought,
Though nothing sure, yet much unhappily.
(Hamlet, Act 4, scene v, l.4-13)
Explanation: Even people around her notice that Ophelia is depressed about her father’s death. Depression sometimes leads people to commit suicide, which in Ophelia’s case is what happened. She was so depressed about her father’s murder that it led her to take her own life.
Reasons why this is wrong:
Just because a person is depressed does not necessarily mean that they will go and kill themselves. Ophelia’s depressions stems from her grief of the death of her father. There are certain stages of grief that a person must go through. During this time, Ophelia is going through the first stage of grief; numbness and shock. Since Ophelia is not in touch with reality at this time, there is no way that she could have committed suicide.
References
Unknown Author, “Grieving.” Canadian Mental Health Association. Canadian Mental Health Association. 15 Dec 2008 <http://www.cmha.ca/BINS/content_page.asp?cid=2-63-65>.
Unknown Author, “Psychosis.” Canadian Mental Health Association. Canadian Mental Health Association. 15 Dec 2008 http://www.cmha.ca/BINS/content_page.asp?cid=3-105.